Business Leadership Today

The Disadvantages of Lower Retention Rates


Matt Tenney, Author of Inspire Greatness: How to Motivate Employees with a Simple, Repeatable, Scalable Process

Employee retention is more than a metric; it is a critical aspect of any organization’s success. It is the backbone that supports the structure of an organization, ensuring its stability and growth. 

High retention rates are proof that an organization is delivering a positive employee experience and fostering engagement. When retention rates are low, it can lead to a domino effect of issues that can severely hamper a company’s progress.

The disadvantage of lower retention rates is the negative ripple effect it can have on an organization’s performance. When retention rates are low, it can lead to loss of knowledge, skills, and cultural DNA, decreased morale, a less positive reputation, and, ultimately, increased costs. 

This article will delve into the disadvantages of lower retention rates.

Loss of Knowledge, Skills, and Cultural DNA

Employees are more than just workers—they are the bearers of the organization’s knowledge, skills, and cultural DNA. 

Each employee brings a unique set of skills and experiences that contribute to the collective knowledge of the organization. They also play a crucial role in shaping and maintaining the organization’s culture.

When employees leave, they take with them not only their individual expertise but also a piece of the organization’s cultural DNA. This loss can have a profound impact on the organization. 

It can lead to a significant gap in institutional knowledge and skills, affecting the organization’s productivity and efficiency. The organization may face challenges in filling this gap, which could result in potential delays and errors.

The departure of employees can disrupt the cultural continuity of the organization. The unique insights, perspectives, and values that departing employees contributed to the organization’s culture may be difficult to replace. This can lead to a dilution of the organization’s cultural DNA over time.

It is essential for organizations to recognize the value that each employee brings, not just in terms of their skills and knowledge, but also their contribution to the organization’s culture. 

Decreased Morale

High turnover rates can have a significant impact on the morale of the remaining employees. 

The constant departure of colleagues can create a pervasive sense of uncertainty and instability. This uncertainty can permeate the work environment, leading to lower job satisfaction and decreased productivity.

The departure of colleagues can also increase the stress levels of the remaining employees. They may feel pressured to take on additional responsibilities, further adding to their stress. This increased stress and pressure can contribute to the creation of a toxic work environment.

A toxic work environment is not just detrimental to the well-being of the employees; it can also be one of the driving forces of turnover. In fact, toxic work environments are recognized as one of the leading causes of employee turnover in the US. 

This creates a vicious cycle where low morale leads to high turnover, which in turn further decreases morale, so leaders should work continuously to maintain a positive and supportive work environment to boost morale and reduce turnover rates. 

Impact on Reputation

An organization’s reputation is one of its most valuable assets. However, a high turnover rate can significantly tarnish this reputation. 

If an organization becomes known for its inability to retain employees, it may find it increasingly difficult to attract high-quality candidates in the future. Prospective employees often consider the turnover rate as a key indicator of job satisfaction and organizational health. 

Websites such as Glassdoor have made it easier for job seekers to gain insight into the type of employee experience an organization offers based on the experiences of previous employees. 

When potential hires come across a considerable amount of negative feedback regarding the employee experience, it’s a red flag that the organization may have a retention problem.

A poor reputation is not just a barrier to recruitment,but it can also affect the organization’s relationships with clients and partners. 

These stakeholders may begin to question the organization’s stability and reliability. They might wonder if the high turnover rate is indicative of deeper issues within the organization, such as poor management or a toxic work culture.

In the worst-case scenario, a poor reputation could lead to a loss of business. Clients and partners may choose to dissociate themselves from an organization with a high turnover rate to protect their own reputations.

Organizations must recognize the far-reaching implications of a high turnover rate on their reputation. By improving their retention strategies, they can enhance their reputation, attract and retain top talent, and foster stronger relationships with clients and partners.

Increased Costs

One of the most immediate and tangible impacts of low retention rates is the increased costs associated with hiring and training new employees. When an organization cannot retain its employees, it finds itself in a constant cycle of recruitment and training. 

These processes are not only time-consuming but also expensive. The costs can quickly add up, straining the organization’s resources and affecting its bottom line.

The loss of knowledge, skills, and cultural DNA when employees leave necessitates the hiring of new employees who need to be trained to reach the same level of expertise. This training requires both time and money, adding to the overall costs. The resulting decrease in organizational efficiency can indirectly lead to increased costs.

Decreased morale among employees can lead to disengagement and lower productivity, which can result in decreased profits. The organization may need to invest in morale-boosting activities or improved employee benefits to retain its employees, which again adds to the costs.

The impact on reputation due to high turnover rates can make it difficult for the organization to attract high-quality candidates. This could lead to the organization having to invest more in its recruitment processes or spending more on advertising vacancies.

Low retention rates can lead to increased costs in so many ways—from the direct costs of recruitment and training to the indirect costs resulting from loss of knowledge, decreased morale, and a damaged reputation. 

How To Improve Retention Rates

While employee turnover is a natural part of business, excessively high turnover rates can have serious consequences. Organizations must strive to improve their retention strategies to avoid these pitfalls and ensure their long-term success. 

Here are five tips to boost retention:

  1. Employee Experience: Foster a positive employee experience by supporting the employee’s journey from their first interaction with the organization during the recruitment process, through their growth and development within the organization, to their eventual exit. This will help employees stay more satisfied and engaged at work. 
  2. Professional Development: Support a learning culture by offering opportunities for professional growth and development. This can motivate employees to stay and grow within the organization.
  3. Recognition and Rewards: Recognize and reward employees for their hard work and achievements. This can boost morale and job satisfaction.
  4. Work-Life Balance: Promote a healthy work-life balance and offer flexibility. This can reduce burnout and increase job satisfaction.
  5. Positive Work Environment: Foster a positive, inclusive, and psychologically safe work environment. This can make employees feel comfortable and happy at work.

By implementing these strategies, organizations can boost retention and ensure their long-term success.

Matt Tenney has been working to help organizations develop leaders who improve employee engagement and performance since 2012. He is the author of three leadership books, including the groundbreaking, highly acclaimed book Inspire Greatness: How to Motivate Employees with a Simple, Repeatable, Scalable Process.

Matt’s ideas have been featured in major media outlets and his clients include numerous national associations and Fortune 500 companies.

He is often invited to deliver keynote speeches at conferences and leadership meetings, and is known for delivering valuable, actionable insights in a way that is memorable and deeply inspiring.

Others Recent Articles and Podcast Episodes

Would you like to dramatically improve employee engagement?

Get a free training video that will show you how to double the number of engaged, motivated employees in just a few months.

Struggling to retain good employees?

Get a free video training that will help you cut turnover in half in just a few months.