Business Leadership Today

Bridging the Gap: Linking Performance Management and Employee Engagement


Matt Tenney, Author of Inspire Greatness: How to Motivate Employees with a Simple, Repeatable, Scalable Process

While many factors play a role in a business’s success, two key factors have an outsized impact: performance and employee engagement. Managing these factors well can make the difference between an organization that consistently meets goals and an organization that habitually falls short. 

A well-designed performance management system can help organizations achieve their goals by ensuring everyone is working toward the same objectives and providing the necessary support and resources to meet them. 

Similarly, a highly engaged workforce can lead to increased productivity, better customer service, and a stronger organizational culture, increasing the likelihood that an organization will achieve its objectives. 

Because of the inextricable link between employee engagement and business performance, it is important for organizations to invest in strategies that align employee engagement and performance management strategies to drive long-term success and growth sustainably.

Linking performance management and engagement is essential because it fosters a culture of continuous improvement and commitment, leading to higher productivity, improved employee satisfaction, and, ultimately, enhanced organizational performance.

This article will explore why these elements should be intertwined and provide tips on managing both effectively.

The Undeniable Link Between Performance Management and Engagement

Performance management refers to the systematic process that organizations use to align their resources, systems, and employees with their strategic objectives and priorities. 

It involves setting clear goals and expectations, providing regular feedback, and assessing progress toward achieving targets. 

Employee engagement is a separate but interrelated process that involves fostering a sense of emotional commitment and loyalty among employees toward the organization and its goals. 

This can lead to employees putting in discretionary effort, going above and beyond the minimum requirements of their jobs, and making valuable contributions to the organization. 

Performance management and employee engagement are intrinsically linked, each influencing the other in a continuous feedback loop. 

A strong correlation exists between employee engagement and overall business performance. For this reason, the value of employee engagement cannot be overestimated. 

Engaged employees are not just invested in their specific roles; they are committed to the organization’s mission and goals. This commitment often translates into higher productivity, innovation, and better business outcomes.

Research has shown that engaged employees tend to be higher performers. They bring passion and interest to their work, which fuels their motivation to perform at their best. 

They are more likely to go the extra mile, solve complex problems, and contribute to the team’s success. Their higher performance levels, in turn, lead to better business results, creating a virtuous cycle of engagement and performance.

However, improving performance is not a straightforward task. It requires a holistic approach that includes addressing the drivers of employee engagement

Performance management systems that focus solely on metrics and fail to consider the human element of engagement will likely not yield the desired business outcomes. Engagement is the key to unlocking employees’ full potential, and without it, performance may plateau. 

The Need for Alignment

Aligning performance management and engagement is a delicate task that requires careful balancing by HR departments. Both elements are crucial for an organization’s success, but they focus on different elements of employee experience.

Performance management is primarily about assessment. It involves setting clear expectations, monitoring performance, providing feedback, and recognizing achievements. Its goal is to ensure that employees’ efforts align with the organization’s strategic objectives.

Employee engagement focuses on active listening and exchanging feedback. It involves understanding employees’ needs, motivations, and perceptions of their work environment. Its goal is to create a positive work environment where employees feel valued, motivated, and committed to their work.

While both elements are important, focusing solely on engagement without linking it to performance management may not serve the organization’s best interests. 

Engagement initiatives that do not consider performance can lead to a culture where effort is not linked to results, which can be demotivating for high performers and detrimental to the organization’s overall performance.

HR departments must ensure their performance management and engagement initiatives are aligned. This means creating a culture where high performance is recognized and rewarded and where employees feel listened to and valued for their contributions.

The Power of a Combined Approach

A combined approach to performance management and employee engagement can be incredibly powerful. It lays the groundwork for long-term organizational success and makes for happier employees. 

This is because when performance management and engagement are integrated, it creates an environment where employees are not only motivated to perform at their best but also feel recognized for their contributions. 

This integration is a two-way street.

On one hand, performance management systems provide clear expectations and accountability, which are key drivers of engagement. Employees who understand their roles and responsibilities and how they contribute to the organization’s goals are more likely to be engaged.

On the other hand, engaged employees are more likely to perform well, contributing to the effectiveness of performance management systems.

The benefits of this integrated approach extend beyond individual performance. It leads to higher profitability and better business outcomes, as engaged employees are more committed, put in greater effort, and are less likely to leave the organization. 

It also contributes to a positive work culture that fosters happiness and satisfaction. In such a culture, employees feel a sense of belonging and purpose, further bolstering their engagement and performance.

Organizations that want to achieve these outcomes track engagement levels and link them to key performance indicators (KPIs), such as productivity, customer satisfaction, and profitability. This allows them to quantify the impact of engagement on business outcomes and make informed decisions about where to invest their resources.

Many data-driven companies have established a culture where data is effectively utilized to make decisions across the organization, including in areas of performance management and employee engagement. 

This approach provides valuable insights that enable companies to identify areas to improve and enhance employee engagement. For example, they might measure employee engagement in a way that improves it by using survey data to identify drivers of engagement within their organization and then target these areas with specific interventions. 

Alternatively, they might use performance data to identify high-performing teams or individuals and then seek to understand what drives their high levels of engagement and performance.

A combined approach to performance management and employee engagement is not just beneficial but essential for organizations seeking to achieve long-term success. By integrating these two areas, organizations can create a positive work culture, drive higher performance, and, ultimately, achieve better business outcomes.

Challenges in Linking Performance Management and Employee Engagement

Linking performance management and employee engagement is not without its challenges. Ensuring that these two elements work together in harmony requires a thoughtful and strategic approach.

One of the main challenges is the difference in focus between performance management and engagement. 

Performance management is often seen as a top-down process focusing on meeting organizational goals and objectives. Engagement is about creating a positive work environment where employees feel valued and involved so that they can meet organizational goals and objectives. Balancing these two aspects can take time and effort.

Another challenge is the risk of superficial engagement initiatives. Some organizations implement engagement initiatives that are not tied to performance management, leading to superficial changes that do not have a lasting impact on employee performance or satisfaction.

Measurement can also be a significant challenge. While performance can be relatively easy to measure through KPIs, measuring engagement is more complex. It involves understanding employees’ emotional connection to their work, which can be difficult to quantify.

There can also be communication challenges. Effective communication is essential for both performance management and engagement; without it, both will suffer. Unfortunately, it can be challenging to communicate performance expectations and feedback in a way that also fosters engagement.

Despite these challenges, the benefits of linking performance management and engagement are significant. With careful planning and execution, organizations can overcome these challenges and create a work environment that fosters both high performance and high engagement.

Tips on Managing Both Engagement and Performance

Modeling Core Values and Mission

It is so important for organizations to demonstrate their core values and mission in all aspects of their daily operations. Simply listing these values in the employee handbook or on the company’s website won’t cut it—these values must be practiced in a way that is visible on a daily basis.  

For true success, employees must observe their leaders and colleagues embodying these values in their everyday actions. When there is a clear alignment between personal and organizational values, employees are more likely to feel engaged and perform at a higher level. 

This is because they feel a sense of ownership and purpose in their work. In turn, this can lead to increased productivity and a stronger sense of community within the organization. 

Asking for and Learning from Feedback

Feedback is a powerful tool for improving performance and engagement. It is an effective tool that can help individuals and teams identify their strengths and weaknesses and work toward growing their skills and abilities. 

To be effective, feedback must be encouraged and valued in the organization’s culture, not just as an individual activity but as a collective practice. Creating a safe and open environment for giving and receiving feedback is essential to fostering trust and collaboration in teams. 

Feedback should also be viewed as a two-way communication process, where both employees and leaders can learn from each other. By actively listening to the feedback that employees give, organizations can gain valuable insights into their employees’ perspectives, experiences, and challenges. 

Ensuring Managers are Engaged

The impact of managers on employee engagement cannot be overstated. In fact, an employee’s direct supervisor affects their engagement the most. As the front-line leaders in an organization, direct supervisors have a direct influence on the level of engagement within their teams. 

When managers are themselves engaged, they are more likely to inspire engagement among their team members. To achieve this, organizations must prioritize equipping their managers with the necessary skills and tools to foster engagement. 

This includes providing training on effective communication, setting clear expectations, recognizing and rewarding good performance, and creating a positive work culture. A strong leadership development program can be an invaluable tool for growing engagement. 

Supporting Employees’ Physical and Mental Health

One of the most significant factors in ensuring high levels of employee engagement and optimum performance is providing support for employees’ physical and mental well-being. 

This support can take various forms, such as implementing health and wellness programs that promote healthy habits like regular exercise and balanced nutrition. Additionally, encouraging work-life balance can go a long way toward reducing stress and burnout among employees. 

A supportive work environment that fosters open communication, collaboration, and positivity can also play a crucial role in enhancing employees’ mental well-being. Overall, investing in employees’ health and well-being is a smart move that can lead to increased productivity, higher job satisfaction, and lower turnover rates.

Recognizing and Rewarding Top Performers

Recognizing and rewarding top performers is an effective way to enhance the morale and productivity of the workforce. By acknowledging the efforts and achievements of employees, you can make them feel valued and appreciated, thereby increasing their sense of loyalty toward the organization. 

This, in turn, can lead to a more engaged and motivated workforce, resulting in better performance and results. Such appreciation can come in various forms, like bonuses, promotions, certificates, or even a simple thank-you note. 

It not only helps to retain top talent but also creates a positive work culture, where employees feel supported and encouraged to perform to the best of their abilities.

Sending Frequent Employee Engagement Surveys

Employee engagement surveys work very well when used properly. Conducting regular employee engagement surveys is a vital step toward building a thriving workplace culture because they allow you to gauge how invested your employees are in their work, identify areas for improvement, and create strategies to boost employee engagement and performance. 

By analyzing the results of these surveys, you can gain valuable insights into the factors that impact employee engagement, such as work-life balance, recognition, job satisfaction, and company culture. 

Armed with this knowledge, you can take targeted actions to create a positive work environment that fosters employee engagement, motivation, and productivity.

Providing Professional Development and Career Path Options

One of the most effective ways to enhance employee engagement and performance is to provide them with opportunities for professional development and clear career paths within the organization. 

When employees know that they have opportunities to learn new skills, acquire additional knowledge, and advance their careers within the company, they are more likely to feel valued and motivated to perform at their best. 

This leads to increased productivity, better job satisfaction, and higher retention rates, as employees are less likely to seek employment elsewhere if they see a clear path for growth and advancement within their current organization. 

Offering Training Opportunities and Programs

One of the most effective ways to improve employee performance and engagement is to invest in their development through training opportunities and programs. By providing employees with the necessary skills and knowledge to excel in their roles, organizations can help them become more confident, productive, and engaged. 

In addition, investing in employee development can be a powerful tool for retaining top talent and attracting new hires who are looking for growth opportunities. 

By demonstrating a commitment to their success, organizations can build a continuous learning culture that benefits both employees and the organization as a whole.

Matt Tenney has been working to help organizations develop leaders who improve employee engagement and performance since 2012. He is the author of three leadership books, including the groundbreaking, highly acclaimed book Inspire Greatness: How to Motivate Employees with a Simple, Repeatable, Scalable Process.

Matt’s ideas have been featured in major media outlets and his clients include numerous national associations and Fortune 500 companies.

He is often invited to deliver keynote speeches at conferences and leadership meetings, and is known for delivering valuable, actionable insights in a way that is memorable and deeply inspiring.

Others Recent Articles and Podcast Episodes

Would you like to dramatically improve employee engagement?

Get a free training video that will show you how to double the number of engaged, motivated employees in just a few months.